Every roster, every bench, every lineup card, checked against what a perfect lineup would have scored. Start rates are ESPN league-wide for Week 5.
Sean Bilger Brotherly Shove
Lost by 43.06 and played the week with no kicker on the roster. Every other team got at least 5.1 from the position. Jacoby Brissett (24.78) at quarterback with Lamar Jackson sitting at 0.0 was the right call, and so was MarShawn Lloyd (16.2) at a 15.0 percent start rate. Kenneth Walker III had the week off with the Chiefs. Colston Loveland got the tight end job back and scored 2.9. Sean has 8.2 points from the tight end slot in five weeks; Ben has 69.8. The Bears defense scored -2.0 in its first start for Sean. A perfect lineup scores 92.48 and loses by 37.96. Of the 23 starters who have scored zero or less this season, Sean started four.
Luke Uliana Remember The Tateans
Won by 22.28 with 154.52, the second-highest score of the week, 6.7 off perfect. Emanuel Wilson (12.2) sat at a 67.5 percent start rate while Chase Brown started for 5.5. That is the whole gap. Jaylen Warren scored 33.8 in the flex and Matthew Stafford 27.32 on Monday night, with Luke down 5.04. Kyle Monangai, 27.5 on the bench last week, scored 0.0. Luke has scored 667.38 points, the most in the league, and is 4-1.
Jeff Darcy Jeantyfication
Lost by 48.76 and is 0-5. Kyle Pitts Sr. started the first three weeks for 0.0, 2.0 and 1.0. He has been benched the last two weeks and scored 6.2 and 12.7. T.J. Hockenson started this week for 1.2. Keenan Allen finally got a start, in the flex at a 7.3 percent start rate, and scored 7.0. KC Concepcion started for 1.0. Chuba Hubbard had the week off with Carolina. Joe Burrow has gone up every week: 14.16, 16.18, 22.58, 23.72, 24.6. A perfect lineup scores 100.50 and loses by 33.96. Jeff has 456.44 points, the fewest in the league, 60.30 behind Devin.
Ben Dudash The McBride
Won by 2.82, first win of the season, with -0.16 from the quarterback slot. Jakobi Meyers finally started, two weeks after scoring 15.9 on the bench, and scored 4.7. Dontayvion Wicks went to the bench and scored 8.8. Tony Pollard scored 7.0, 11.6 and 12.0 on the bench in Weeks 2 through 4, started this week, and scored 5.2. Spencer Shrader kicked for 21.3 and the Texans defense scored 15.0. Josh Jacobs has been on the roster all five weeks and scored 0.0 in every one. Ben has had 648.12 points scored against him, the most in the league. A perfect lineup scores 119.04.
Lovell Bivins Taking out the Trash Panda
Lost by 84.50 with the low score of the week, 81.70, and the biggest bench in the league, 55.06. Lovell benched Calvin Ridley for the first time since Week 1 and Ridley scored 4.3. Mack Hollins kept his spot at wide receiver: injured reserve, projected 0.0, started by 0.21 percent of ESPN, the lowest start rate of any starter in this league this season. He scored 0.0. The Packers defense scored 19.0 on the bench at an 8.1 percent start rate while the Steelers defense started for 1.0. Brock Purdy (16.16) sat behind Jalen Hurts (13.0). Lovell has started the lower-scoring quarterback in three of five weeks. A perfect lineup scores 111.16 and loses by 55.04.
Steven Cortright X Gon' Gibbs It To Ya
Won by 43.06, a third straight win after an 0-2 start. Jahmyr Gibbs scored 35.2, his third game over 30 this season. Also left 28.50 on the table, the second-biggest gap in the league. Roman Wilson started at a 9.4 percent start rate and scored 0.0. David Montgomery scored 1.1 with Blake Corum (14.7) on the bench. A perfect lineup scores 158.94, which would have been the second-highest score of the week.
Daniel Martisofski Buffalo!!!!
Won by 16.24 after trailing by 23.86 going into Monday night. Is 5-0. Three Bills started on Monday and scored 52.8 between them. DJ Moore was one of the three, projected 0.0, and scored 0.0. Moore has scored 18.5, -0.1, 9.7, 2.2 and 0.0. Terry McLaurin (10.2) sat. Christian Watson scored 29.3 at a 76.2 percent start rate. A perfect lineup scores 143.98. No payout this week; Dan is tied for second in the money race with two.
Davis Martisofski Hill Street Blues
Lost by 2.82 after leading by 16.78 with nobody left to play. Jordan Love scored 25.28 on the bench while Bo Nix started for 7.92; that swap wins by 14.54. Ladd McConkey started at wide receiver, projected 0.0, and scored 0.0 for the second straight week, with Courtland Sutton (8.8) sitting; that swap wins by 5.98. CeeDee Lamb, started by 98.2 percent of ESPN, scored 1.9 on Thursday. Isaiah Likely scored 26.9 in the flex. A perfect lineup scores 136.48. Davis has left 93.8 on the bench this season, the most in the league.
Sal Cicero LaPorta Potty Love
Won by 84.50 with 166.20, the high score of the season and the biggest margin. Started Aaron Rodgers (22.0) at an 11.0 percent start rate, with Bryce Young on bye and Jayden Daniels on the bench for the third straight week. Daniels scored 32.26. RJ Harvey got his first start of the season, in the flex, and scored 0.7, one week after 14.3 on the bench. Jason Myers kicked for 25.0. Puka Nacua, benched in Weeks 2 and 3, has scored 23.2 and 29.2 since. A perfect lineup scores 183.56. Sal has the high team score two weeks running and leads the money race alone with three payouts.
Devin Golden Iavana Humpalot
Lost by 16.24 with the only perfect lineup in the league: a perfect card from this roster scores 114.44, and Devin scored 114.44. Patrick Mahomes and Travis Kelce were on bye. Dak Prescott started and scored 12.64. Malik Washington held the flex at a 12.3 percent start rate and scored 9.1. Saquon Barkley was on the bench at 0.0. Devin led after the late games and after Sunday night and lost to three Bills on Monday. That is the third time this season Devin has led after the late games and lost. 1-4, four straight losses.
Joshua Smith Ja'Marr Ja'Marr Binks
Lost by 22.28 with 132.24, the most points in a loss this season. Jared Goff scored 28.94 and Parker Washington 27.4. The Cowboys defense scored -2.0 on Thursday at a 39.5 percent start rate. Denzel Boston (12.1) sat for the fifth straight week; he has scored 12.9, 18.0, 7.1, 10.9 and 12.1 on the bench, 61.0 points without a start. Caleb Williams, 37.26 in Week 1, has been on the bench at 0.0 for three weeks. A perfect lineup scores 138.24 and still loses. 1-4 with the fifth-most points in the league.
Brent Balga Gruden's Grinders
Won by 48.76. Drake Maye scored 39.46, the high starter of the week, and Brent has his first payout of the season. The Week 3 obituary for Maye asked the family for a backup. Sam Darnold sat on the roster in Week 4 and was gone by Week 5, and Maye scored 26.16 and 39.46 in the meantime. Brent started three wide receivers at start rates of 1.9, 2.9 and 8.5 percent, Dohnte Meyers, Tre' Harris and Makai Lemon, and they scored 11.6 between them. The Jets defense scored 18.0. 2-3.